Dry Comfort
The waiting is the hardest part
Every day you get one more yard
You take it on faith, you take it to the heart
The waiting is the hardest part – petty
I had a student in a class recently who told me a story of the new Gore-Tex dry top his parents bought him last Christmas. From there it didn’t go well. Whenever he put on the dry top, his head and his hands turned red and swelled up like balloons. He’d lose feeling in his fingers. He complained of not being able to breathe very well. His parents wanted to return it right away. He didn’t. He’d read on the internet that dry gear could be uncomfortable and he simply needed to “get used to it”. Finally though, his parents won out. They sent it back.
When I heard this story, I could envision the whole thing. I’d heard it before. I’d been there myself actually. When you don’t have any frame of reference and just do a bit of web surfing, you quickly come away thinking dry gear is meant to be uncomfortable. Of course that’s not the case. When those of us who wear dry gear regularly use the word, “uncomfortable” we don’t mean strangled, swelling and red.. That’s something completely different. We usually mean it in the same way that some guys don’t like wearing neckties, more phobic than threatening. Your head should not be turning the color of a discarded beet.
Happily today my favorite delivery guy showed up today with a cool new black Kokatat Gore-Tex Rogue Dry Top. This gives me the opportunity to walk you through the steps I take to make the top nice and comfortable. It will take me a few days to get it where I want it, but you’re welcome to follow along.
The first thing I did this evening of course, was just try on the top. I put on a few base layers under the top just to be sure I’d have extra room when it got cold outside! The top fit fine. The only downside was that I had to pull on the neck gasket the whole time or I’d go woozy from the lack of oxygen. I could also feel my pulse thumping away in both wrists. This is the situation the student I mentioned above had found himself in. Of course, I’ve been here before so I know what to expect.
You read a lot online about trimming gaskets, but we don’t want to go there. Not just yet anyway. The latex will stretch a bit. I can’t tell you how much exactly, but over time the latex will become more comfortable on its own. To rush things along I’ve put wide jars through both wrist gaskets. (see the picture above) If you don’t have jars try soda cans or a bit of fat PVC pipe.. whatever.. just something round that you can stretch the latex over. For the neck gasket a coffee can is great. I found an old vinegar bottle myself. Again, anything round that will stretch the latex yet won’t tear the gasket will do. Now the hard part comes… The waiting. I’m going to let my gear stretch out over night and try it again tomorrow. I’ll probably then have to let them stretch another day or so. I’m going to give them time. I’m not in a hurry to trim anything. Once you start cutting… Well, as they say, “You can’t go back.”
I felt bad that the student I mentioned didn’t know what to expect when he first got his new dry top. He probably went through a lot of unnecessary disappointment and discomfort when in fact he and his parents were making pretty intelligent decisions.
Stay tuned…
* Update: All it took was overnight with the jars to make the wrist gaskets comfortable. The neck also loosened up quite a bit, but I might have to do more with that yet.

Did your student maybe have a latex allergy? Apparently, they’re surprisingly common. Rash, hives, red skin, and difficulty breathing are all symptoms of a latex allergy.
Good thought, but his description was simply that the seal was too tight on the neck.
I guess I may be the only person who feels this way, but if I spend this much money on an item, it should fit right straight out of the box. I tried stretching the gaskets on a dry top that I had once (same method as you have described), and after a week, they all were still too tight. I tried wearing it to see if I could get used to it, and that didn’t work either (red face, swollen purple hands). I could not bring myself to cut the gaskets, so I sold the dry top (at a loss) and never looked back. I still don’t have any dry gear, and I still don’t paddle in the winter.
If I can buy a dress shirt off the rack with the correct neck size, I should be able to get a neck gasket the same way.
I understand what you are saying Richard. The problem with drygear however is that in order to work they have to fit uniquely snug. Not blindingly tight, but snug as Russ mentions. Day to day clothing like a dress shirt can be slightly loose and who’d know? You’re not trying to keep water out.. On the other hand I know what you mean about the anxiety of cutting. I feel that now, and I’ve done it a few times. It just feels wrong to be taking a razor to new gear, not to mention the worry that you’ll make a mistake.
I think the new neoprene versions would be idea for you since they will “fit” off the rack. http://www.kokatat.com/products/paddling-suits.html Remember dry gear isn’t only for winter, it’s important survival gear anytime you risk exposure to water for any extended length of time. Spring & early summer is probably when the gear could do the most good. I loose count every year on how many paddlers get in trouble in cold spring water.
I’ve found many people who live with gaskets which were too tight and a few who even sold their suits because they couldn’t get comfortable in the gaskets. What these people all failed to understand what that the gasket does not need to be very tight to work properly.
Since buying my first drysuit years ago, and having bought another suit, 2 drytops, and a couple periodic gasket replacements, I now immediately trim the neck gasket.
You are correct in that latex does relax over time. On the other hand, over-stretching it will damage it. In the case of a Kokatat gasket, once one knows how many rings to trim off, (neck gasket) the process can be repeated on every Kokatat gasket of that size.
Trimming a new suit gasket seems like scary stuff, but once one knows how it should feel when worn, it is very often the right thing to do.
Hey Russ!
Good thoughts. Yeah, they don’t need to be very snug. I think I know where to trim my gasket, but this time it felt much more flexible than the ones I’ve had before. I wore it paddling without trimming it yesterday in fact. I think I’ll end up taking one ring off, but still.. I think latex has softened up in the last 5 years of so.
I think there could be better communication to new buyers about getting the feel right, etc., There certainly isn’t a lot of communication up front about the proper fit/gaskets in any catalogs or shopping carts that I’ve seen. Something to think about..
All the comments on the gaskets are good. Myself, I’ve been lucky w. drysuits. The gaskets (neck and wrist) fit me as is.
Here is my problem with most drytops.
They are not cut for people with breasts – C cups and above – who have a slender torso. If they can be pulled over those kind of breasts, they are too big elsewhere in torso and sleeves.
If they fit elsewhere, then they do not fit over those size of breasts. It is no fun paddling w. one’s breasts squashed in.
Not even the women’s cuts have worked.
That is all
Good point. I know quite a few women who have had this problem as well, with a variety of paddling gear. I don’t know about other companies by I know Kokatat will make drytops/suits to measure. I’d think that would help resolve that issue.
Good to know, thanks.
Kokatat is well known for their willingness to customize. As it is, I have two drytops currently, a Palm Sidewinder and a BomberGear Hydrology. The BomberGear cut is superior. (Both are a men’s small) and the Palm drytop has more features. I probably should have gotten a Palm Naiya (Women’s specific) but it was just so hard to find… and now Palm’s distributorship is the U.S. underwent some changes and I don’t know how warranty issues are addressed.
I look forward to having the extra pennies someday to get a Kokatat Rogue for Women.
AFAIC, when it comes to drywear, it’s just better to go Kokatat straightaway.